Thursday, February 5, 2009
The American Board of Internal Medicine released the results of last October's Hospice and Palliative Medicine Board exam today. At this point as far as I know we only have individual results, and not data such as overall pass rates, etc. It looks like Neurology has announced certifications as well (I plugged in the current AAHPM president Russell Portenoy to check).
I don't know about other boards (I randomly checked Pediatrics and Gyn and couldn't find anything), and someone commented already today on a prior post that the Family Medicine board has indicated it will post results tomorrow (February 6).
Congratulations to all who passed or who are about to pass - this is a huge milestone for our profession.
Sorry about the extra post - I'm not wanting to clutter people's inbox but I figure this is worth it.
Thursday, February 5, 2009 by Drew Rosielle MD ·
Wednesday, February 4, 2009
Welcome to the inaugural edition of Palliative Care Grand Rounds, a monthly blog carnival bringing you the best and most interesting blog posts about hospice, palliative care, death and dying, grief, quality of life, communication in the medical arena, and anything else that strikes the fancy of the host that month.
If you are interested in becoming one of the upcoming hosts, please comment or email me at ctsinclair @t g-m-a-i-l d0t c0m. Here is the website with the archives and upcoming hosts.
If I ever get some spare time maybe we will get a creative little logo going.
Dethmama Chronicles is going to be the next host on Wednesday March 4th. (PCGR is a monthly blog carnival on the first Wednesday of each month.)
Don't feel you have to read all of these at once. Come back and nibble a little bit at a time. And if you read the posts from the other authors, leave a comment and let them know you want to see more!
FROM THE STAFF
Dr. Bob Wachter reviews the recent Archives of Internal Medicine paper showing patients have difficulty naming their doctors. He discusses many lessons learned from this study in his blog post. As you read it consider if palliative care teams suffer from the same problem. With all the members of your team it could be hard to remember who is who. But I imagine with increased face to face time discussing weighty matters it members of the palliative care team may be easier to recall. But currently that is just an untested hypothesis. Sean or Nate could you get on this?
Dethmama always enlightens and entertains with her recollections of interesting home visits as an on-call hospice nurse. The good ones this month are: "The Photo Op" with a surprise twist ending!, "A Talk with a Doc II", and "Hospice Hitwoman and the CYA."
A palliative care NP named Risa reflects on the bewilderment of family at how clinical inertia can overcome advance directives before anyone pauses to notice in her post "How Did This Happen?" She has another great post titled "Drifter" about how easy it can be to give someone a little respect when they were never given any.
Leo Levy at DNR/DNI completes the "My Code" saga. Great narrative style. Here is an example:
The code gets up to full speed. One of the nurses asks how many times we are going to do this. “Someone needs to bring the family!” I call out. This time my words find purchase. Eyes turn to the fellow. The rest of the team does not know about our conversation. Will she take this as a challenge to her authority? There is a moment of tension in the room. “It’s alright, go get the family,” she saysHopeful LSW at Confessions of a Young Looking Social Worker posts the many reasons why she loves her job as a hospice social worker. Here are a few of my favorites from her post:
A man who helped build the Sears Tower (I was in awe of his courage)How do you want to die? In your sleep? Nibbled to death by the piranhas of senescence? Ask Duncan Cross.
A woman who was heavily involved in promoting a woman's right to vote and began several activist groups in her town...and continued to do her part after suffering a stroke at age 40...after the birth of her 6th son. Talk about strength!
A man who was a steeplejack, a trade he learned from his uncle that no longer exists
HospiceNP lets us know the difference between "the work" and "the job."
Kevin MD brings attention to why it is so difficult to die in American hospitals.
Is being a hospice doctor depressing? Dr. David Tribble from the Alive Hospice Blog (welcome to the show Alive Hospice) lets you know it is not so depressing.
Dr. Bernstein from the Bioethics Discussion Blog asks which state is next for legalizing physician assisted suicide? What do you think?
Tigermom at Two Women Blogging posts a story about a friend with metastatic cancer who is also a therapist for others with severe illness. Does helping others cope, help you cope?
Aggravated DocSurg spins a story about the death of a trauma patient using the Four Horsemen as a unifying theme. Good literary stuff! Here is an excerpt:
Surgeons and anesthesiologists really don't like it when patients die in the OR, so after the "ex fix" has been placed and the femur appropriately splinted, Billy Bob takes his final ride tour of the hospital, to the ICU. Cold, coagulopathic, and comatose, there is nothing else that can be done, and Billy Bob continues to hemorrhage and eventually develops cardiac dysrhythmias and dies.Good bedside manner is a key trait for the effective palliative care clinician. When your conversations sometimes go from zero to death in five minutes then you realize how empathy, compassion and good communication skills are wonderful assets to posess. Dr. Centor discusses the responsibility for attending physicians to model and teach good bedside manner. His blog post was spurred by a recent Pauline Chen article about the same issue in the NY Times.
FROM THOSE IN THE KNOW
There are so many interesting posts from Jessica Knapp at The Good Death that I could not just pick one. As a PhD candidate she is focusing on communication as a way to improve the way we approach death and dying. She covers mortuary bands, rights of same-sex partners in illness, and online grief support sites. But my favorite has to be "Cybertime" in which her mother opens a Gmail account and finds 177 unread emails from her recently deceased father. It is a MUST READ STORY!
Niko Karvounis at Health Beat Blog discusses the "Danger of For-Profit Hospices" in our future health care system with the awareness of the rapid expansion in the last decade and the increased scrutiny to the Medicare Hospice Benefit. ANOTHER MUST READ!
Les Morgan from Growthhouse has a great summary on funeral information and questions to ask. Would be great in pamphlet form!
Bill Colby, JD, known for his work in the Cruzan case and now a senior fellow at the Center for Practical Bioethics asks a very important question: Can Living Wills Work?
Tim Cousinais from the Palliative Care Success blog asks an important question and we need some answers: Will health reform accelerate or stall the progress of palliative medicine?
Wesley J. Smith has been a vocal opponent against euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide on his blog Secondhand Smoke. He recently posted a video called "The Euthanasia Blues." The only song I know with 'palliative care doctor' in the lyrics. For a good reflection of the chord this song strieks with people make sure to read some of the comments on his blog and on You Tube. Thaddeus Pope of Medical Futility writes about Smith:
"Smith often broadly attacks end-of-life mechanisms like PAS and unilateral withdrawal, even though such mechanisms can be invoked in justifiable circumstances. Nevertheless, he (and this video) are correct to imply that such mechanisms can be (and are) sometimes illicitly employed."FROM THE PATIENT & FAMILY
Cancer patients have capitalized on the use of blogs to extend social support networks. The ability to update many with a few minutes at the keyboard seems so simple and yet the lives it impacts is so powerful. Anna Douglas, a popular BMJ blogger chronicling her experience with cancer died on February 1st. Her blog, From the Other Side, was started in April of 2008, and there are only a score of posts, but many offer great insights to her treatment.
HopefulLSW made note of another blogger with cancer, Kindra McLennan, who died on January 2nd of this year. Her post makes note of a Chicago Tribune story about the impact of Kindra's blog and some notable posts.
NPR's contribution to the cancer patient blogosphere has persisted despite the death of the initial blogger Larry Sievers. His wife offers reflections on her bereavement now that Larry is no longer with her. It is now expanding to a community titled, "Our Cancer." A recent post covered the occasional non-fit of a hospice nurse and a patient, but thankfully that experience did not make them turn their backs on hospice support forever. This would be the second time a hospice person would come into our home. The first time was a bad fit. We both couldn't wait for her to leave. So this time around, we were a little nervous.
Gail Rae from Mom & Me Journals relates the thin line caregivers walk when caring for a patient in decline when it comes to nutrition and hydration in her post "I Trust her with my Life." She compares her experience with a 1994 Law & Order episode entitled Golden Years, which focuses on formal and informal caregivers in conflict about feeding a frail home bound elderly woman.
Thanks for reading all the way to the end of the first edition of Palliative Care Grand Rounds. I hope you enjoyed some of the links. Any feedback about this new initiative would be great!!!
Wednesday, February 4, 2009 by Christian Sinclair ·
Monday, February 2, 2009
(This is the third in a series of 5 posts (#5, #4) about issues in hospice & palliative medicine I think will be important in the next year. Feel free to disagree!)*
#3 Dealing with Medically Hastened Death
In a world where a women can give birth to 8 children, the abilities for science and medicine to control the beginnings and ends of life is unparalleled to any other time in history. As experts in the medical care of dying people, the public will look to us for guidance and measured discussion with regards to the political firestorm that is euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide/death. Physician-assisted suicide (PAS) is already legal in Oregon and now Washington state and potentially Wyoming.
If palliative care is patient centered how do we advocate for total care but stop short of full autonomy when it comes to the actual time of death. Is a neutral approach the best? Should we lead and help support or oppose legislation? Will this issue split our currently congenial and very supportive community along ideological lines? We educate and counsel so many families and patients about good end-of-life care on an individual level, so what is our responsibility to the greater public? These questions keep me up at night. And I am afraid I alone do not have the answer.
The AAHPM issued a new statement on Physician Assisted Death in 2007. It supports physicians in states where PAD is legal, while at the same time urges great restraint in wielding this power. Have you read the AAHPM's position statement? Any thoughts? If Compassion and Choices wanted to sponsor a speaker at a palliative care conference or place advertising in palliative care journal would would be the appropriate response?
Sometimes it is easier to just not think about these things, but it does not make them go away.
Monday, February 2, 2009 by Christian Sinclair ·
Image via Wikipedia
This year the Annual Assembly is in Austin, TX from Wednesday March 25th until Saturday, March 28th.)
Wednesday March 25th Pre-Conference Workshops
All Day Sessions (8a-5p)
Hospice Medical Director Course—Module C: Administrative Issues and Challenges (P1)
In a rotating fashion, Modules A, B and C all get their turn in the spotlight. While the blurb in the handout does not say anything explicitly about the new Medicare Hospice Benefit Conditions of Participation, I sure hope they cover these since there are going to be a lot of changes in the future in what it means to be a hospice medical director (more phone calls and paperwork in a more timely fashion methinks.) Any help in navigating the new COP's would be great for the busy hospice medical director.
CPC Social Worker Workshop (P11)
The College for Palliative Care is sponsoring the only no fee pre-conference. There is no mention of the Social Work in Hospice and Palliative Care Network being a part of this, but it is mentioned on their website. Sessions given by social workers and chaplains (or other non-nurse/physicians for that matter) are rare at the Assembly, but my hope is that sessions like this encourage more diverse interdisciplinary faculty at future palliative care educational conferences.
Half-day Sessions - 8a-Noon
Practical Approaches to Palliative Wound Care (P2)
I am so there. I have missed so many major wound care talks because of conflicts at past Assemblies so this year I am determined to go to this. The best part is the blurb describes the session as hands-on, so I have already started to work on my own decubitus!
Communication Skills for Transitions in Goals of Care (P3)
The creators of Oncotalk (Back, Arnold, Tulsky and Baile) present their unique system on addressing the dynamic landscape of goals of care. Oncotalk was developed initially for Oncology fellows and has been going for 3-4 years now (someone please correct me if I am wrong). The program was born out of PDIA and NIH grants. For someone needing to brush up or hone their goals of care talks this is the session you need.
Ethics Skills Building Workshop (P4)
Palliative care has usurped many an ethics consult with good communication and focusing on what the patient and families needs are. Most palliative care consultants have so much ethics experience they are frequently asked to be on ethics committees but what qualifies one to be on a ethics committee? I hope they move beyond the traditional paradigm of autonomy, beneficence, non-maleficence and distributive justice. Most people are pretty familiar with these principles, but a good palliative care clinician should extend their ethical paradigm to consider a wide range of principles and ethical approaches.
Grief and Its Multi-faceted Nature: A Clinical- and Skill-Oriented Workshop (P5)
The blurb says role-play will be included which I think is a great idea for any of these interactive sessions. But is it always good to put role-play in your blurb if you are trying to induce people to come? Or is it better to spring it on them once they are there? My vote? Spring it on 'em, the words role-play scare people away IMHO.
Creating Pediatric Hospice and Palliative Care Programs and Fellowships (P10)
A niche talk to be sure, but one that is necessary so that we can stop freaking out adult medicine docs who realize they may HAVE to do pediatric palliative care because they are the only game in town!
Half-day sessions 1p-5p
Hospice in Long-Term Care: Regulations, Ethics, Quality, and Collaboration (P6)
If ever there was an area that needed more collaboration and understanding it would be hospices and nursing homes. There is much potential for synergy, but frequently different regulatory systems and cultures conflict, so I am glad to see this session here. I am debating between this and Advanced Pediatric Pain Management (P8). If only I were more excited about regulations.
Making It in a Man’s World: A Leadership Boot Camp for Women in Health Care (P7)
All they need to do is come to Kansas City. I am surrounded by women in strong leadership roles in my hospice clinical work and with the University of Kansas fellowship program here (now accepting applications for 2009 & 2010! We are accredited!). Seriously, a great outside the box topic that helps our field succeed. And what a great list of presenters: Periyakoil, Block, Meier, Ferrell, Ritchie. So good choice for a session, but obviously not for me. ;-)
Advanced Pediatric Pain Management (P8)
Still debating between this and the LTCF session, since I see more pediatric patients then LTCF patients. Would like to hear more about subanesthetic ketamine protocols since we don't prescribe that frequently. And when it comes to pain control in pediatric patients there is still a fear of opioids and undertreatment is common, so any other tools would be great to have.
Translating Patients’ Wishes into Medical Orders: The POLST Paradigm (P9)
POLST is really making a path across the country. As I look over some of the forms, I wonder how well they are received by families as we discuss the use or discontinuation of antibiotics. Sometimes these discussions feel like walking a tightrope based on patient and family hesitancy to commit to any concrete course of action. Since I don't live in a POLST state (yet) I guess I will have to wait and see. Or I could also go to this session.
CPC Physician Workshop—Next Steps in Competency-Based Assessment for HPM Fellowship Training: Identifying Assessment Tools and Giving Specific Feedback (P12)
Longest title contender for sure. Glad to see Laura Morrison at the helm of this talk. She was one of my first friends at the 2004 Annual Assembly after we chatted about ICD deactivation. And VJ Periyakoil is presenting at this one also? How can she present at three conferences? Maybe she has superpowers and can be in two places at once. If so I must meet her. (It is getting late while I write this...can you tell?)
Stay tuned for more previews in the next week or two. Early registration is due February 11th!
by Christian Sinclair ·
In 2007 and 2008 I posted previews for the AAHPM/HPNA Annual Assemblies. I started doing the preview because one of my favorite things about conferences is talking to other people to see what they are interested in, so feel free to comment on which sessions you are excited about. If you are giving any of these talks, I encourage you to leave some comments to get more people aware of your talk. There are some good ones!
This year the Annual Assembly is in Austin, TX from Wednesday March 25th until Saturday, March 28th. (2009: Boston - cool!; 2010: Vancouver - cooler!)
I wanted to point out some of the new features at the Assembly this year in this post, the other post today will cover the Wednesday pre-conference sessions.
Rounding with the Stars: What a wonderful idea to get more case based discussions at the Assembly! I am really glad to see this addition since the Professionals-in-Training Case Conference initiative was started as a response to the overwhelming shift towards didactic sessions at the Assembly in years past. The session is described as interactive so if you attend make sure you speak up!
Special Interest Group (SIG) Symposia: The Academy has fostered communities through the SIG system and giving each SIG a slot to present something relevant to its' members is a good way to elevate the influence of the SIG, thereby creating interest in joining a SIG. Very chicken and egg!
Going Green: Well it is very trendy these days to go green, and the Annual Assembly is now wisely asking us to make choices about the impact we make as a group. Do you really need another tote bag? How cool would you be if you just brought your tote bag from the 1993 conference?
Paper Sessions Now Without Distractions!: Although it is not mentioned in the 'What's New' section, keen observers will note this is the first year (in my short experience) paper sessions do not have to compete with other concurrent sessions. The verdict is out on whether this increases paper session attendance or gives people a reason to take a break. My vote is for the former.
One should really try to attend at least one paper session at a conference to get a a great deal of focused information on multiple subjects in a short period of time. Some things should really be explained in 15 minutes instead of a hour long session.
Photo by Flickr user by CraigAllen
by Christian Sinclair ·
Thursday, January 29, 2009
Cancer has a paper about treatment preferences and hospice enrollment, focusing on African Americans. The data comes from structured interviews with 300 cancer patients at a single cancer center, which included questions about treatment preferences as well as self-reported need/interest in home services. Consonant with other research (for instance this recent paper in JAGS demonstrating higher rates of hospitalization and ICU use at the end of life amongst African Americans), African American patients reported a greater willingness to undergo cancer treatments with a low likelihood of benefit in the last 6 months of life, compared with white Americans. African Americans also reported a greater interest in and assigned higher utility to hospice services (the services weren't described specifically as 'hospice' services, but instead different home services provided by hospice care were described separately), although this difference seemed to be mostly due to economic status (and disappeared when controlling for economic hardship).
The authors conclude that African American cancer patients' needs, at least as described by this study, aren't particularly met by the current US hospice model. They are less likely to be eligible for hospice care (using these treatment preferences as a proxy for eligibility since you technically have to forswear life-prolonging treatments to be eligible for hospice under the Medicare Hospice Benefit), yet have self-reported needs for hospice services which are higher in general than white Americans (even if this is largely due to economic hardship and need). These issues are certainly not unique to African Americans; these data however support the idea that these issues are accentuated for them. They conclude:
For 25 years, hospice services have been restricted to patients in the last 6 months of life who are willing to give up curative treatment. Although this restriction was intended to control costs, it has substantially reduced access to hospice for many patients who have needs for hospice services, and a disproportionate number of these patients are African American. This eligibility criterion should be reconsidered, and needs-based criteria should be considered to make hospice eligibility criteria both fairer and more consistent with eligibility criteria for other health insurance benefits.Obviously this is what the 'home-palliative care' and 'open-access hospice' models have been trying to address and we'll see how successful these movements are, and given the economic climate (and Medicare floating the idea of paying less for patients with longer stays despite everyone for a long time beating the drum to try to increase hospice lengths of stay) it seems highly unlikely that the needs of sick, symptomatic patients receiving chemotherapy are going to be met by our current and future hospice models. This would be fine if we had another robust system in place, but we don't (at least nationally - the Kaiser home palliative care model and others are available to some in certain areas), and so we muddle along.
Thursday, January 29, 2009 by Drew Rosielle MD ·
1)
The American Journal of Surgery has an interesting read - a qualitative look at medical student 'moral distress.' (Moral distress defined here as 'the negative feelings that arise when an individual believes he or she knows the morally correct response to a situation, but cannot act because of hierarchical or institutional constraints.) It looks at case summaries written by 3rd year medical students and analyzes them for themes surrounding descriptions of moral distress. Issues surrounding death, dying, hope, communication are a distinct part of the discussion. Some of the wisdom of these students is impressive. One wrote, 'But my observation was that more desperately than their need for answers was their need for kindness. And while we may not have had the ability to provide the answer, we certainly had the ability to provide the kindness.'
Thanks to Dr. David Weissman for alerting me to this.
2)
Age and Ageing has a systematic review on the natural history and prognosis of persistent delirium in older hospitalized patients. It adds to the literature on persistent delirium (see related post here) as a major marker of morbidity and early death in older patients. The data here are hampered of course by differences in definitions of delirium, follow-up, etc., and I wouldn't put a huge amount of stock in the actual numbers presented, but the finding that persistent delirium is a poor long-term prognostic sign seems irrefutable. Most interesting to me were the handful of studies which followed patients for multiple months suggesting that many older patients (mean age in these studies was in the early 80s) who are delirious during a hospital stay remain permanently cognitively altered afterwards (the way they define delirium here I hesitate to say they remain 'delirious' as opposed to permanently cognitively impaired, as well as there's a decent amount of variation in the studies between patients who presented delirious vs. those who develop it while hospitalized, as well as the data aren't broken down by who had dementia at baseline). Anyway - a few of the studies which followed patients for 6 months found a substantial minority (~10-30%) remain altered at 6 months. Yikes.
Thanks to Dr. Bob Arnold for alerting me to this.
3)
Pain Treatment Topics (a free, online collection of original publications - often very practical/clinically-oriented papers - along with other resources to do with all things pain), recently published a hard-look at what is known and not-known about the prevalence of opioid-abuse in patients receiving prescribed opioids for chronic pain (free pdf here - page 6), concluding more or less that what research is out there does not support the idea that prescribed opioids cause addiction or that opioid-abuse is inordinately common in these patients. Of course, and unfortunately, none of the research is definitive, but I think this is a good counter to publications such as this one in a highly influential journal: read the abstract (or the full article) which to the casual reader suggests a world of badness and then read my post about what the article actually says about abuse/addiction and chronic opioid therapy. No doubt that abuse/addiction is a problem in patients with chronic pain, but how much of a problem is not yet even well-defined, let alone the role of prescribed opioids in causing/maintaining the problem.
Image is a thumbnail from Pain Treatment Topics 'pain art' page.
4)
There's a new health policy blog out there which has been covering hospice and end of life issues quite well: Health Beat at http://www.healthbeatblog.org. Check out these recent posts about for-profit hospices and the new MedPac proposals to decrease hospice payments for a patient the longer they are enrolled.
Thanks, again, to David Weissman for letting us know about this.
by Drew Rosielle MD ·
Cancer has a paper looking at the prognosis of leptomeningeal carcinomatosis. It's a single-institution (Spain) case series looking at 70 patients diagnosed with leptomeningeal carcinomatosis (LC), and gives some prognostic data. Mean age was 55 years, ~40% each had breast cancer and lung cancer (the remainder being a smattering of other solid tumors), and about half received specific treatment directed at the LC. The median overall survival was 21 days (although with a range up to 2000+ days). Of those who received intrathecal chemotherapy, median survival was 108 days. Good performance status, higher CSF glucose, and the presense of 'infratentorial' (cranial nerve and spinal symptoms) as opposed to 'supratentorial' symptoms (e.g. seizures, encephalopathy) were associated with improved survival. Apparently cancer type was not associated with survival in this series. Patients who received no chemotherapy were older, with worse performance statuses, etc. and it's impossible to say how much of the survival difference is due to underlying factors vs. treatment effects.
by Drew Rosielle MD ·
Tuesday, January 27, 2009
Journal of Clinical Oncology has an Art of Oncology piece about the role of investigational therapies in patients with refractory cancers - specifically arguing that it is very important not to give up 'hope' too soon and to make sure patients are informed about investigational therapies 'positively.' Two, rather remarkable, case descriptions are included, including one of a man with hairy cell leukemia who apparently was told for over 20 years with each relapse that he 'should receive palliative care,' chose instead investigational treatments, and did really well for a long time.
Fine. The cringe-inducing problem here is with their rhetoric around the term 'palliative care' as exemplified best by this palliative care = abandoning hope paragraph:
The distinction between palliative care and participating in investigational therapeutic protocols is the issue of hope. A move to palliative care requires that the individual accept a state of hopelessness. Many patients turn to unproven remedies to restore hope. In the case of investigational therapeutics, the patient is willing to participate in a process that offers not only hope for the patient as an individual, but makes a substantial contribution to the body of knowledge that will benefit patients in the future. Therefore, though there may be a point at which continuing therapy is unrealistic, or when the comfort offered from palliative care is preferable, it is crucial to acknowledge how difficult it is for anyone to know when a patient reaches this point. Breakthroughs, by definition, imply successful treatment in a situation that was previously considered hopeless.Obviously, this is not what one wants to read in the pages of JCO. To play devil's advocate (with myself I guess), it is important to realize that we really do have a problem in palliative care with terminology which is confusing all around, and we haven't been able to fix this (yet). The problem is that there are many (overlapping) flavors of meaning of 'palliative' and 'palliative care':
- A descriptive term which describes the non-disease-modifying-but-hopefully-quality-of-life-improving-ie-symptom-alleviating aspects of medical care (delivered in whatever settings by whomever and without any implication one way or the other if disease-modifying/life-prolonging care is being concurrently given). Similar to, but often used a little distinctively, from 'supportive care.' Not necessarily given by 'palliative care' clinicians.
- A descriptive term to describe a global approach to the medical care of a patient (given by whomever) which is solely symptom-alleviating without any disease-modifying aspects (in certain circumstances such as when a patient is receiving this care near to death some people call this 'comfort-care' or 'comfort-only care'). Not necessarily given by 'palliative care' clinicians.
- Care given by specialist-level palliative care clinicians and teams (which depending on the situation always involves attempts at 'quality of life improving care' but may or may not involve giving or advocating for life-prolonging interventions and under no circumstances should imply one way or the other if disease-modifying care is being concurrently provided or not)
- Heck it's also used for disease-modifying but non-curative interventions as well ('palliative chemotherapy' to refer to life-prolonging but non-curative chemo, a whole range of 'palliative' surgeries)
- I'm sure there are other flavors as well.
An excellent editorial touches on those issues, and goes into much more detail about how the piece is perhaps a wee bit off target, albeit in a polite and less wheezy manner than me above. There is sort of a 'phuleeze' quality to the editorial (as in it's not exactly fair to only use examples about hairy cell leukemia - a disease with fantastic and remarkable treatment breakthroughs in the last decades unlike most solid tumors - as well as suggesting maybe perhaps there is more of a problem nationally with poor quality end of life care (etc. etc.) and not so much with patients being inappropriately railroaded into 'palliative care'?). Maybe? Perhaps?
Tuesday, January 27, 2009 by Drew Rosielle MD ·
1)
Health Affairs has an article from the Dartmouth Atlas people looking at inpatient care intensity and patients' rating of their hospital experiences. Like much of the DA research it looks at administrative Medicare data (specifically regional variations on spending, intensity of care such as hospitalizations, physician utilization, etc.), and using a mortality-follow back design (patients selected for the study had already died). This paper looks at how patient satisfaction ratings compare with that and finds, consistent with other DA research, that more is not better. Patients in the highest utilization regions (for some reason there is a huge spike in the Kansas City region, and given how Christian is talking lately on the blog about how he loves to reverse DNR orders I figure it's got to be due to him**) had the lowest satisfaction (regarding aspects of their hospital care like physician and nurse communication, pain control, etc.).
Hospice use at the end of life did not differ regionally (30%) however no data is presented about length of hospice enrollment. By itself these sort of data don't mean much - maybe there are regional variations in how whiny and dissatisfied patients are and how demanding they are of medical care (or other regional confounders). However this is part of a larger pattern that has emerged (from the work of the DA people and others) that more (more expensive, more intense, more hospital-focused) care for the sickest patients is plainly worse care, however you measure it: mortality outcomes, quality measures, and patient satisfaction. And hell if 'more care' doesn't do any of those things then what are we doing? Interestingly the authors speculate at the end that the 'causal pathway' in these high-utilization regions leading to worse outcomes is due to lack of 'care coordination'...
2)
...Which brings us to the next paper suggesting this phenomenon in a specific circumstance. It's from Archives of Internal Medicine and looks at continuity of care in cancer patients and how it affects ICU use at the end of life. It's a retrospective study using administrative data (the SEER database and Medicare data) to look at associations with care continuity and ICU usage in ~28000 advanced lung cancer patients who died in the US between 1992 and 2002, and who were hospitalized in the last 6 months of life. The key aspect they looked at was if their 'usual care provider' (essentially a physician who saw the patient at least 3 times in the year prior to the index hospitalization) actually saw the patient in the hospital (they looked at the patients' final hospital stay prior to death), and if that was associated with differences in ICU use.
Across the 10 years of the study out- to in-patient continuity declined (the usual care provider seeing the patient in the hospital) from ~60% to ~50%. Many of the usual suspects in care discontinuity were found to be associated with an ICU stay: academic hospital, large metro areas, non-White race. Specifically looking at care continuity they found that it was, in fact, 'protective' against an ICU stay in the final hospitalization (19% vs. 23% of patients without continuity - in the multivariate analysis odds of ICU stay were reduced by 25% with continuity). Really interesting was the very strong association of being cared for by a hospitalist (defined in the study as a doc with over 50% of their billings being inpatient based) with having an ICU stay. The authors speculate that this association was explained by lack of care continuity.
All of this has me speculating about the role of palliative care teams in this. While this is somewhat of a free-association based on my own observations of what I frequently do on the inpatient consultation service, it seems that what we often are doing (or trying to do) is essentially a 'work-around' for this lack of continuity by providing lots of care coordination (how many of you frequently do consults in which your major intervention was getting everyone to talk to everyone at the same time?) as well as trying to provide some of the more ephemeral aspects of care that continuity is supposed to provide (trust, patient-centered care based in a patient's values and goals, etc.).
**This is a joke. Christian, I'm sure, does wantonly waste medical resources but probably not in this way. Kansas City is in the middle; Newark, LA, Miami, Manhattan, and Chicago are at the top.
Thanks to Drs. David Weissman for the Health Affairs piece.
by Drew Rosielle MD ·